 |
Heroes Forum
Spoilers & Theories
Hiro Nakamura
Fan Site
 |
|
SuperHiro.org Unofficial Heroes NBC Forum and Message Boards
|
Live Chat Monday During Heroes!
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Hercules67 Benefactor Voted Least Awesome! "You have a problem with that, punk?" -- Great Teacher Onizuka

Joined: 14 Nov 2006 Posts: 3377 Location: No particular place Reputation:     votes: 13 2647.08 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items 
|
Posted: Fri Aug 29, 2008 9:53 pm Post subject: |
|
|
[quote="Action Figure"]
| Darcy wrote: |
| Hercules67 wrote: |
That is so lame....
If time is stopped, nobody should be able to move but the person who stopped time and a person like Peter who shares that ability.
HEROES is going down the STUPIDEST paths... |
Also, no.
This makes perfect sense. Hiro Slows time to an unnoticable crawl, essentially making himself move so fast(realtively) he goes unseen. Daphne moves so fast she goes unseen, essentially slowing those around her down (relatively) to an unnoticable crawl.
Boom!  |
You missed the POINT.
If Hiro stops time, he STOPS time. You're saying, that somewhere, they have definitively said (they being the writers) that Hiro DOES NOT stop, but rather slows time down to a crawl.
If that's your answer, of course then, I agree with you -- HOWEVER,
If, he does actually stop time, everywhere in the world for everyone (as I seem to recall one of the writers having said in Season 1), then I stand by my comment: This is VERY LAME. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Guaxini Dreams of Flying...


Joined: 28 Nov 2007 Posts: 47
Reputation:                                                                 votes: 2 46.01 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items
|
Posted: Fri Aug 29, 2008 11:05 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| so i guess in a way they are each able to slow down things around them (or speed themselves up relative to objects around them), but daphne can't teleport like hiro, and hiro can't run 100 miles like daphne without getting exhausted. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Guaxini Dreams of Flying...


Joined: 28 Nov 2007 Posts: 47
Reputation:                                                                 votes: 2 46.01 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items
|
Posted: Fri Aug 29, 2008 11:15 pm Post subject: |
|
|
and i agree that if hiro completely stops time, rather than just moving with a speed so much greater than everything around him (whereas the velocity of these objects can said to be negligible) than unless daphne also actually manipulates time rather than just running fast, it makes no sense for her to be able to move while time is stopped.
however, it could be that hiro is going so much faster than everything around him that the velocity of these objects/people is negligible giving the appearance that time is stopped. the writers may have said in the past that he stops time, but that may have been because they, just as hiro, just as us, believed that time was completely stopped, whereas they now realize that it only appears so. i'm going to go with this if it is the case that daphne can move at normal person speed when hiro "stops" time.
i remember an argument that for hiro to be able to reverse time that for it to go from positive time to negative time (normal to backwards) that it has to pass through 0. but this doesn't have to be the case. it could be undefined at 0 which is why it only moves really slow. a simple example of how it could be undefined at 0 but still pass from positive to negative is the function f(x)= 3x/x, and it makes sense that hiro could pass from positive to negative without crossing 0, considering that when he time travels he jumps from one point in time to another, therefore the timeline is not continuous between those two points. suppose we set his origin of time as august 29th at exactly 5:18:00 PM. Hiro sits around for a few minutes and decides to see what will happen in one hour. So he travels there. Time is continuous from 5:18:00 PM to whenever he leaves, around 5:20. but it is not continuous from 5:20-6:20. therefore, if time doesn't have to be continuous from 5:20-6:20, why does it have to be continuous and pass through and be defined at 0 in order for him to reverse it? sorry to get mathmatical. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Hercules67 Benefactor Voted Least Awesome! "You have a problem with that, punk?" -- Great Teacher Onizuka

Joined: 14 Nov 2006 Posts: 3377 Location: No particular place Reputation:     votes: 13 2647.08 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items 
|
Posted: Sat Aug 30, 2008 12:08 am Post subject: |
|
|
Two problems:
Time is non-linear.
And,
Heroes is a TV show, so they can do whatever they please.
So arguing is mute. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
kac Hears Others Thoughts... Spoiler TRACKER. Cuts ands pastes like no ones business.

Joined: 29 Feb 2008 Posts: 422
Reputation:                                                                    votes: 7 408.98 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
deftonesdea Hears Others Thoughts...

Joined: 26 Nov 2006 Posts: 485
Reputation:   votes: 1 130.91 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items
|
Posted: Sat Aug 30, 2008 2:06 am Post subject: |
|
|
just wanna stop in to say "thx 100% a BUNCH" to kac....
its been a long time coming but, i appreciate what you do ALOT, i have to admit you're posts were a bunch of jumble at first, but i've found my way...they've gotten alot better, and , yea its hard to get the comics---hiros references (although i read em all the time)
i appreciate your commitment+effort, thanks oh so much, keep it up!
p.s. - comics are awesome |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Action Figure Mimics Powers... Ive got THE HUNGAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Joined: 27 Feb 2007 Posts: 1829 Location: Richmond, VA. Reputation:     votes: 24 4839.44 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items
|
Posted: Sat Aug 30, 2008 3:36 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Hercules67 wrote: |
Two problems:
1. Time is non-linear.
And,
2. Heroes is a TV show, so they can do whatever they please.
3. So arguing is mute. |
1. Time is a dimension. It cannot equal zero, if it did time would no longer exist.
2. You're exactly right. They can do whatever they want. And clearly they want to say that they dont think Hiro stops time anymore, he just slows it. It doesnt matter what they've said in the past. new evidence suggests they've changed their minds.
3. No, the point is moot. Unless you've gone deaf... but we arent speaking aloud...
But really, isnt ALL discussion on a tv show moot? Alas, this is a forum, so we must ignore that so that we may discuss something we like...  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Darcy Has Mirror Twin...


Joined: 27 May 2008 Posts: 232
Reputation:                                          227.94 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items
|
Posted: Sat Aug 30, 2008 3:56 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Action Figure wrote: |
| Hercules67 wrote: |
Two problems:
1. Time is non-linear.
And,
2. Heroes is a TV show, so they can do whatever they please.
3. So arguing is mute. |
1. Time is a dimension. It cannot equal zero, if it did time would no longer exist.
2. You're exactly right. They can do whatever they want. And clearly they want to say that they dont think Hiro stops time anymore, he just slows it. It doesnt matter what they've said in the past. new evidence suggests they've changed their minds.
3. No, the point is moot. Unless you've gone deaf... but we arent speaking aloud...
But really, isnt ALL discussion on a tv show moot? Alas, this is a forum, so we must ignore that so that we may discuss something we like...  |
Technically, time isn't a dimension, for the exception of Hiro and Peter, and any other people who can bend time. Time is changing at a constant rate for everybody else. But you're right, time cannot equal zero because there's just no such thing. It's just like the argument that there was no year zero in the argument of when the new millennium began. However, there was a time that could be defined at zero, and that's the beginning of time.
As for the whole deal with Hiro and Daphne, Hiro both exists inside and outside the limits of time. He can exist inside of time, and he can exist outside of it. Whether or not evidence suggests he slows time down a lot instead of freezing time doesn't mean that one is necessarily correct. Evidence suggests F. Peter should be able to heal, but he still has the scar. Evidence would suggest he's not even in the right time line. So how can he exist in the wrong time line? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
popkorn615 Moderator ~~Theory Master~~

Joined: 23 Oct 2006 Posts: 3532 Location: New York City Reputation:     votes: 31 1335.98 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items 
|
Posted: Sat Aug 30, 2008 5:19 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Action Figure wrote: |
PK, egyptians pulled the brain out through the nose, so Im sure Sylar could manage through the mouth.
 |
Why do you know everything!
Lol
ACTION!!!!
YOU MIGHT HAVE STUMBLED ONTO SOMETHING!! Egyptians pulling out brains through the nose... THE GRAPHIC NOVEL WITH THE EGYPTIANS AND ONE OF THEM POSSESSING TELEKINESIS TO MOVE BLOCKS? Coincidence??... or more than that...?
| Darcy wrote: |
My theory is that Echo is Angela and Charles son, especially given his last name being DeMille, quite similar to Deveaux. Peter is quite possibly Linderman's son since they both want to heal people. My guess is Arthur didn't have that depressive disorder, it was just Linderman's "delusions of grandeur" they were worried about.
Could anybody see F. Sylar getting killed off by Knox? |
That's a nice theory about Angela + Charles = Echo, Darcy! I'd definitely down for accepting that.
The only reason I think Peter might NOT be Arthur's son is because Arthur favors Nathan more - Maybe Arthur knew that Peter was not his, but had to suck it up and accept the fact that he had to 'pretend.'
Whoa whoa whoa, I have a NEW THEORY...
What if Peter and Claire were in the same SITUATION as BABIES!!! Meaning, in the same way that HRG was given Baby Claire, what if Angela was GIVEN BABY PETER to take care of, and the reason she was so adamant about not wanting them to realize their potential was because she didn't want either Peter or Nathan to be discovered! Any takers?
| Action wrote: |
what sylar needs is the Haitian's ability.
but i love the haitian. so i hope not...
oh... and Peter has the Haitian's ability already.... hm... |
Yes, I definitely think he needs to gain this ability. Like I said... I know it would seem anticlimactic, but I would love to see Peter and Sylar's final battle as a hand-to-hand combat battle with both of them using The Haitian's power against each other...
| Herc wrote: |
If time is stopped, nobody should be able to move but the person who stopped time and a person like Peter who shares that ability.
HEROES is going down the STUPIDEST paths... |
I agree... I know that there's no such thing as "stopped time" or "zero time," but as you said, the writers can do whatever they want because it's a TV show, and it's their rules, and they have CLEARLY, verbally, stated in the past that Hiro stops time. However, even though it may seem like they have changed their minds, they still have never clearly stated that Hiro does not fully stop time. The season hasn't even begun yet! So IMO, Hiro still stops time because the writers say he can. And Daphne can breach that time stop.
| Action Figure wrote: |
| No, writer's have said Peter gains ALL abilities. He has ALL of Sylar's powers... hes only seen one of them used, though, so he doesnt realize it most likely. Although, I don't believe he ever saw phasing, but has used it. I think this was a mistake by the writers. |
I agree, with both of your points. Phasing was a HORRIBLE mistake on the writers part. In my opinion, it was the MOST significant inconsistency that we saw in Season 2.
You know what I think happened with that? Well, the writers had Peter phase out of the rope in "Lizards" right? Which makes perfect sense. He didn't know he could, he just did. Well, I don't think that the writers knew exactly how they wanted "Four Months Ago" (episode to play out when they were writing the script for "Lizards" (episode 2). Thus, when they finally came to episode 8, they must have thought to themselves, "Oh, remember, we had Peter phasing in episode 2, so we can have him using it again in episode 8" not realizing that episode 8 takes place BEFORE episode 2. That's my explanation for their poor decision making in regards to Peter's phasing.
| Guax wrote: |
| however, it could be that hiro is going so much faster than everything around him that the velocity of these objects/people is negligible giving the appearance that time is stopped. |
I like that theory a lot, Guax, especially because of how specific it is. I remember physics and calculus back in high school, and I do recall certain values that are either so large, or so small, or differences that are so negligible that it would ultimately be given a value of "zero" or "infinity" in some cases. And this is why I like your explanation, Guax - because it gives it actual scientific substance.
So, if I had to create an visualization for Hiro's time stop, it would look like a hyperbola, where the Y-axis represents the "speed of time flow", and when Hiro time stops, he actually slows down time to a point where it forever is constantly decreasing in speed, but never touching the X-Axis (zero). Yeah, I know time is a dimension, but I'm just trying to give it a visual explanation and support my thought somehow
| Guax wrote: |
| i remember an argument that for hiro to be able to reverse time that for it to go from positive time to negative time (normal to backwards) that it has to pass through 0. but this doesn't have to be the case. it could be undefined at 0 which is why it only moves really slow. a simple example of how it could be undefined at 0 but still pass from positive to negative is the function f(x)= 3x/x, and it makes sense that hiro could pass from positive to negative without crossing 0, considering that when he time travels he jumps from one point in time to another, therefore the timeline is not continuous between those two points. suppose we set his origin of time as august 29th at exactly 5:18:00 PM. Hiro sits around for a few minutes and decides to see what will happen in one hour. So he travels there. Time is continuous from 5:18:00 PM to whenever he leaves, around 5:20. but it is not continuous from 5:20-6:20. therefore, if time doesn't have to be continuous from 5:20-6:20, why does it have to be continuous and pass through and be defined at 0 in order for him to reverse it? sorry to get mathmatical. |
That was me who brought up the "crossing over 0" point, and you just geniusly proved me wrong with a perfect explanation. I completely lost sight of undefined values in science and mathematics... and you so clearly, eloquently, and perfectly provided a scenario. Don't apologize for getting mathematical - I love it, and understood every second of it. This also goes back to the graph of a hyperbola, where 0 is undefined. Kudos my friend! Many many kudos for your thoughts!
| Def wrote: |
| just wanna stop in to say "thx 100% a BUNCH" to kac.... |
Yeah, seriously... Kac, your contributions to the forum are amazing, as always. Once your "title change" wears off, I bestow upon you my former titled of "Spoiler Master" - I lost that a long time ago, lol, and you have more than earned it over the past year. So change your title haha! If you don't, I will lolll Thank you again for spoiling us. "We're not worthy! We're not worthy!!" |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
jocko7 Has Mirror Twin... Number 1 Super Guy!!!

Joined: 09 Oct 2007 Posts: 254
Reputation:                                                                                               votes: 3 251.98 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items
|
Posted: Sat Aug 30, 2008 7:37 am Post subject: |
|
|
I think we need to start looking to the graphic novels for more hints. If you remember my previous posts about "Walls", where Peter & Hiro were freeing Nicki from prison, there was a moment where they were "unable to stop time". This was due to the presence of Daphne and her super speed. (Now Verified) Granted, I don't think the writers had clearly thought out their story (or does it only appear that way?). Nonetheless, we see in an early novel a power revealed only to show itself in a SECOND SPOILER on camera for SEASON 3! Lets give the Graphic Novels a little more credit than we have been...
I think Season 3 is going to be great. Spoilers and hints filled with more Surprises. Awesome.....
By the way, I think Daphne's power is explained in simple terms. She moves at such fast and accelerated speed (faster than super sonic flight obviously - ANOTHER SPOILER? Running faster than Nathan can fly. Hey, Flash was faster than Superman - right?) that she is arriving at moments in time that have "not yet happened". Think of it as a sort of time moving forward at normal speed, and she moves in "blessed acceleration" which is on the "verge of ALMOST breaking the time barrier" - thus she is on the verge of arriving to a future point faster than time itself. On the other hand, Hiro's power works by a different mechanism - teleportation - essentially forgoing the "need for speed". He can manipulate the time speed (as has been theorized) to the point of also being able to "teleport backwards". Not sure if that makes any sense, but I like it in terms of a "COMIC STRIP". (Which is the epitomy of this series. I mean, Fantastic Four and "cosmic radiation". Enough said. Did we pick apart the Spider Man series this way?)
Comic Strip being the key points Ladies, Gentlemen, Kids, and all Heroes Fans. Its not like we're trying to discover the secrets of Chaos Theory, Quantum Physics, Some Undiscovered branch of science, and all at the same time solve the very mysterues of life all in 3 Seasons of a TV Show made to "entertain". This isn't MIT productions meets Nasa. It's Hollywood entertainment. Let us not forget that. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Darcy Has Mirror Twin...


Joined: 27 May 2008 Posts: 232
Reputation:                                          227.94 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items
|
Posted: Sat Aug 30, 2008 11:18 am Post subject: |
|
|
Thanks PK, the other thing I think about Peter is that Nathan is something like in his 40's, and Peter's only like 28. It only seems logical that they decided to stop at one child, Nathan, but was given Peter. Seriously, who neglects their child for someone in their late teens? Would you neglect your 6 year old child for someone probably over 20? I seriously doubt it. But obviously, Angela cares more for Peter than she does for Nathan since she told him "You were always my favourite, I cannot lose you."
I also think the Echo situation is because of that statement that Echo's known her for a long time, even if he can't remember it. Sounds like he got Haitian'd, which we've talked about several pages back that the Haitian works directly for Angela. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Darcy Has Mirror Twin...


Joined: 27 May 2008 Posts: 232
Reputation:                                          227.94 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items
|
Posted: Sat Aug 30, 2008 11:27 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Oops. Almost forgot to talk about your point Jock. You make a lot of sense, even your point on Hiro. I don't actually agree though. Hiro's said he can bend the space/time continuum. That's what I think he actually does, he literally bends it. Meaning he can bend space so he can move himself wherever he wants at any particular moment, and he bends time so imagining time as a loop, he can bend that loop so that he goes to a different time. Also with bending time, he can bend it so it's continuously staying at a certain point of time, and he can probably stretch time so it slows down, or compact time so it goes faster. But he doesn't exist in time, so he's unaffected by these changes. As for Daphne, when Hiro loops time at a particular moment, Daphne's quick reflexes allows her to still move. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
JessicaSanders Benefactor


Joined: 08 Feb 2007 Posts: 319
Reputation:   3284.20 Waffles
[ GET WAFFLES ]
Items
|
Posted: Sat Aug 30, 2008 1:10 pm Post subject: |
|
|
the graphic novels gave the spoiler about jessica and dl's gang before it was actually full yknown. they really do give info and spoilers.
that one was funny. "to the left to the right YANK" |
|
| Back to top |
| |